Tape 3, 2000 April
Loading the media player...
Transcript
Transcripts may contain inaccuracies.
- | Sensitivity training. | 0:00 |
One of the reasons that when I get on the staff | 0:01 | |
of the United Church of Christ Commission for Racial Justice | 0:03 | |
and we're doing all those police brutality | 0:05 | |
hearings in New York City. | 0:07 | |
The reason I do a ten-page chronology | 0:09 | |
of police brutality cases for the previous ten years | 0:11 | |
is because I knew what to do from SNCC. | 0:15 | |
That training came to me from SNCC. | 0:19 | |
It's not because I dreamed it up, | 0:20 | |
it's not because I knew it | 0:21 | |
from knowing it myself. | 0:23 | |
What happens is that you realize the necessity | 0:26 | |
for always having a factual base | 0:29 | |
for the information that you're giving out | 0:31 | |
so people just don't think that you're | 0:33 | |
making it up. | 0:34 | |
- | I'm going to go ahead. | |
- | Yeah. | 0:35 |
- | Okay, I have been told we're down | 0:37 |
to about a minute and a half at this juncture, | 0:39 | |
so we'll entertain your questions. | 0:41 | |
Sir, go ahead. | 0:43 | |
Or your comment. | 0:44 | |
Student | My question is | 0:45 |
do you know as far as my generation, | 0:47 | |
young black male and females, what is going on, | 0:49 | |
and I just want to figure out how -- | 0:51 | |
What would be the best way for them to see | 0:54 | |
the past and take the past and bring it to the future? | 0:56 | |
Because the struggle is not over | 1:00 | |
and we still have a long way to go to get there. | 1:01 | |
It feels as though they're being pacified in this time, | 1:04 | |
that, 'Okay, we're done, we don't need to work hard, | 1:07 | |
'we don't need to struggle, we don't need | 1:09 | |
'to do this again, go through that.' | 1:11 | |
What attitude did you all have at that age | 1:12 | |
that made that conviction so strong | 1:14 | |
that you all changed everything? | 1:16 | |
That's what I'd say. | 1:18 | |
- | I walk around, okay? | 1:21 |
The answer to that question ... | 1:25 | |
Are you in school now? | 1:26 | |
Student | Yes, sir. | |
- | In college? | 1:29 |
Student | Yes, sir. | |
- | Get your degree, okay. | 1:30 |
Let's take 40 years ago. | 1:34 | |
How many of you here are students at Shaw | 1:36 | |
now in this room? | 1:39 | |
Anybody? | 1:41 | |
About 40 years ago, if you were a student at Shaw | 1:42 | |
about to get your degree next month, | 1:44 | |
you would've had to scramble to get a decent job | 1:48 | |
if you were not a teacher or going into a government agency. | 1:52 | |
Today, that is not true. | 1:58 | |
The unemployment situation here in the Raleigh area | 2:00 | |
is one of the lowest in the world. | 2:03 | |
All you need to do is to get your education | 2:05 | |
and you step immediately into the middle class. | 2:09 | |
Everything you need to do, and this is one of the things | 2:12 | |
that's causing so much poverty within the black community, | 2:15 | |
is to stay with your family and take care of your family. | 2:19 | |
A major cause of poverty in the black community today, | 2:24 | |
young black males leaving their families | 2:28 | |
and not taking care of them. | 2:32 | |
So number one, get an education | 2:33 | |
and you step immediately into the middle class. | 2:35 | |
Dissenter | I protest. | 2:39 |
- | Would you please? | 2:41 |
- | Would you please, sir? | 2:42 |
- | Poverty is a consequence | |
of four hundred years of racism ... | 2:45 | |
Muriel | Let him finish and then we'll hear from you. | 2:46 |
Dissenter | And those young black males | 2:50 |
are already in poverty. | 2:51 | |
Woman On Panel | Well, so why don't you come next? | 2:53 |
Dissenter | Their behavior | 2:56 |
is a reaction to poverty and not being -- | 2:57 | |
Muriel | Okay, let me say two things. | 2:59 |
One is -- | 3:01 | |
(applause) | 3:02 | |
- | Hey, Thomas. Hello, Reverend -- | 3:05 |
(laughs) | 3:07 | |
Might've expected a SNCC meeting. | 3:08 | |
- | I think that black people will join under the system | 3:09 |
and then proceed to do what George Will does | 3:13 | |
and Pat Robinson does and say, 'It's only a few | 3:15 | |
dysfunctional black people who cause | 3:20 | |
a problem with America,' are doing nothing | 3:22 | |
but putting on a year 2000 definition | 3:24 | |
of racism of 1850. | 3:28 | |
(applause) | 3:31 | |
- | Okay, first -- Excuse me. | 3:35 |
I'm the moderator. First, Hank. | 3:37 | |
Would you finish your comment? Thank you. | 3:39 | |
And then we'll hear from other people. | 3:41 | |
We may have to take another couple of minutes | 3:42 | |
to round this one out, okay? | 3:44 | |
- | Thank you very much. | 3:47 |
I stand by what I said. get your degree. | 3:50 | |
Get your education. | 3:54 | |
You step immediately into the middle class. | 3:56 | |
(disagreement in audience) | 3:59 | |
Woman On Panel | I'm sorry, who has the floor? | 4:00 |
Muriel | He hasn't finished, Reverend. | 4:04 |
They got to hear from you. | 4:06 | |
Dissenter | I am continuously -- | 4:07 |
Muriel | Okay, but you are out of order, brother. | 4:09 |
(Dissenter continues) | 4:12 | |
Brother. Brother. | ||
Dissenter | And they cannot find a stable home, | 4:16 |
neither in | 4:18 | |
Muriel | Okay. | |
I agree with you. | 4:19 | |
(Dissenter continues) | ||
Dissenter | Or sales or in social service. | 4:20 |
Muriel | I would agree with you, but this is not | 4:22 |
the way we're gonna -- | 4:23 | |
(Dissenter continues) | ||
(hits podium) this is not they way we're gonna proceed. | 4:24 | |
This is not the way we're going to proceed, brother. | 4:28 | |
No, you are out of order. | 4:30 | |
(Dissenter continues) | ||
You are out of order, brother. | 4:32 | |
You are out of order, and I am not gonna let you speak. | 4:34 | |
Now, I'm the moderator. | 4:39 | |
Woman On Panel | Thank you. | 4:41 |
Muriel | Okay? | 4:42 |
Go. | 4:44 | |
- | Just to sum it up, get your education, | 4:46 |
take care of your family and the last thing | 4:48 | |
in living legacy as far as I'm concerned, | 4:52 | |
and this is one man's opinion of what | 4:55 | |
the civil rights movement has done, | 4:57 | |
it has expanded and literally, if you will, | 4:59 | |
created the black middle class. | 5:02 | |
Without a middle class, no group of people -- | 5:05 | |
Without a middle class, no group of people makes progress. | 5:09 | |
This country has been a magnet for those who come here | 5:14 | |
hoping to get into the middle class | 5:19 | |
and that has happened. | 5:21 | |
In the 1960s and prior to us getting involved | 5:22 | |
and knocking down these laws, we were not allowed | 5:27 | |
as a people to enter the middle class. | 5:30 | |
You go to college so that you can become | 5:34 | |
a part of that middle class. | 5:36 | |
You get an education. | 5:38 | |
I know the word middle class unfortunately | 5:41 | |
has become a pejorative term for some folks. | 5:44 | |
But folks, when you go to college, | 5:49 | |
you don't get a degree so I can become a better poor person. | 5:51 | |
You get a degree so that you can have a standard of living | 5:54 | |
that is good, that you can support you family. | 5:58 | |
Basically, this is what has happened today | 6:02 | |
and this is the legacy, this is the fruit | 6:05 | |
of what we have done. | 6:08 | |
Muriel | I'm gonna -- Okay. | 6:10 |
Hank, I'm gonna cut you off. | 6:11 | |
I'm gonna close this one out and I'm gonna | 6:12 | |
lay something out for the group | 6:15 | |
because we've been told we have to close. | 6:16 | |
Let me say this to you. That's Hank's opinion. | 6:18 | |
That's not all of our opinions | 6:21 | |
and I want you to be clear about that. | 6:23 | |
I work in prisons every day, okay? | 6:25 | |
I work with brothers who are coming in | 6:28 | |
with the college education, okay? Et cetera. | 6:30 | |
So I want you to know that while Hank is providing | 6:33 | |
his viewpoint -- And Hank was a part of us, | 6:36 | |
and that's one of the things I wanted to say, | 6:39 | |
that we always had room for everybody's opinions. | 6:41 | |
(agreement in audience) | 6:44 | |
This is a very big world. | ||
There are millions of people that you hope to move. | 6:47 | |
You're not gonna channel everybody down the same highway. | 6:49 | |
People are going down other highways. | 6:52 | |
The point of the matter is, with the way | 6:54 | |
that you are gonna proceed in life, | 6:56 | |
do you see the minefields? | 6:58 | |
Are you in the position to make a decision | 7:00 | |
that is on behalf of people? | 7:03 | |
Will you engage in things that are on the other side? | 7:05 | |
Will you join the people who are enemies of the people? | 7:08 | |
You understand what I'm saying? | 7:12 | |
And these days are very problematic, | 7:13 | |
and you can tell just from this brief entree, | 7:15 | |
that there were differences and there | 7:18 | |
continue to be differences. | 7:20 | |
So I'm gonna yield to the conference coordinator here | 7:22 | |
who's asked us to close this session. | 7:27 | |
Hopefully, we can take some of this fire | 7:30 | |
onto the next level and try to get | 7:31 | |
some more into this discussion. | 7:34 | |
Brother, did you want to say something? Okay. | 7:35 | |
Sister, there you go. | 7:37 | |
Coordinator | Thank you. | 7:38 |
Muriel | Thank you. | 7:39 |
- | Let me just echo what was just stated, | 7:45 |
and let me tell you something as you take out | 7:49 | |
your program pieces and take a look at them. | 7:52 | |
There will be lots of wonderful opportunities | 7:57 | |
for us to engage in these discussions both formally | 7:59 | |
by means of the various workshop sessions that are planned, | 8:03 | |
and also by means of the chatroom | 8:08 | |
which we will have available. | 8:11 | |
The chatroom is not the computer chatroom, | 8:13 | |
it's a room where you can enter | 8:16 | |
and there will be SNCC veterans who will be there, | 8:19 | |
and they may or may not have similar opinions. | 8:23 | |
In fact, they may have opposing opinions. | 8:26 | |
And I think that would be a wonderful opportunity | 8:29 | |
for young people to hear the varying opinions. | 8:31 | |
We don't want anybody to leave angry with anybody because -- | 8:35 | |
Well, I won't say what my former ex-husband | 8:39 | |
used to say about opinions and parts of the body, | 8:41 | |
but we all have them. | 8:44 | |
Yes, Dr. Payne, you're trying to get my attention? | 8:47 | |
[Dr. Payne] I was gonna suggest | 8:49 | |
if other people want to view this discussion, | 8:51 | |
so for those who really want to do that, | 8:52 | |
you can use the first afternoon session in the chatroom | 8:55 | |
to start off specifically around questions. | 8:57 | |
- | Exactly. | 9:00 |
Muriel | That's fine, that's good. | 9:01 |
- | Let me then share with you some | 9:02 |
information that you don't have. | 9:05 | |
If you have this piece of paper that says | 9:06 | |
Thursday, April 13, | 9:08 | |
please look down at the first thing is 11:30, lunch. | 9:12 | |
Some of you signed up to go to the | 9:18 | |
Peace Lunch Forum which will be over at NC State. | 9:20 | |
It's there because that program is one | 9:25 | |
that's been in place for many, many, many years. | 9:29 | |
They do lots of wonderful things and bring various speakers. | 9:31 | |
In being a part of this celebration, they asked | 9:34 | |
that they do their traditional program there. | 9:37 | |
So we're inviting those of you who've already | 9:41 | |
signed up to go to go over there. | 9:43 | |
What about your lunch? | 9:45 | |
Well, it will be in the Talley Student Center | 9:46 | |
and you can purchase your lunch in the Talley Student Center | 9:49 | |
or if you happen to be on the second round of shuttles, | 9:52 | |
you can get lunch from around here someplace, | 9:56 | |
but be ready to get on the shuttle. | 9:58 | |
We will have shuttles provided for you | 10:00 | |
to go over to NC State, and we will | 10:03 | |
bring you back from NC State. | 10:06 | |
That will take place between 11:30 and 1 P.M. | 10:08 | |
Then, starting at 1 P.M., when we come back, we will | 10:13 | |
come back to the Raleigh Convention and Civic Center, | 10:16 | |
which is across Wilmington Street, all right? | 10:19 | |
It's right next door to the Sheraton hotel. | 10:23 | |
It's a part of that complex that's | 10:26 | |
on the Fayetteville Street Mall. | 10:28 | |
That's where the afternoon concurrent sessions will be held. | 10:30 | |
I'm going to read the sessions, | 10:34 | |
I'm going to read the names of the persons | 10:37 | |
who are going to be on those sessions | 10:40 | |
so somebody doesn't come up to me later and say, | 10:42 | |
'Who's doing that?' | 10:44 | |
But I will tell you that I'm a teacher | 10:47 | |
and I only like to give instruction -- | 10:52 | |
I'm also a grandmother, and that's | 10:54 | |
what I tell my grandchildren all the time. | 10:55 | |
I'm gonna tell you one time. | 10:57 | |
- | [Woman In Audience] Is this printed | 10:59 |
anywhere for the panelists, even? | 11:00 | |
- | Unfortunately, it isn't. | 11:01 |
Now, let me just try and explain what happens | 11:04 | |
when you try and do something like this | 11:06 | |
and you've got bits and pieces | 11:08 | |
coming from all around the country. | 11:09 | |
We don't all get it all when we need to have it all | 11:12 | |
so that it can be concise, but we're gonna | 11:15 | |
work with it, we're gonna help as much as we possibly can, | 11:17 | |
we're gonna try and do something special for the panelists | 11:20 | |
because I know they're gonna be concerned about it. | 11:23 | |
For the benefit of everyone else right now, | 11:25 | |
I'm gonna read out who's doing what | 11:27 | |
and the room numbers that you can look for | 11:30 | |
when you go to the Civic Center, okay? | 11:32 | |
Starting -- Yes? | 11:36 | |
Man In Audience | You don't have enough people | 11:38 |
for a variety of different panels. | 11:39 | |
Muriel | Yes, that's right. (laughs) | 11:41 |
- | Brother Payne, let's have a meeting. | 11:45 |
There's been a proposal we don't have enough people | 11:49 | |
for a variety of sessions when | 11:52 | |
we do the concurrent sessions. | 11:55 | |
Given the number of people who have registered, | 11:59 | |
they must be somewhere. | 12:02 | |
What do you want to do? What do we want to do? | 12:05 | |
[Payne] I just have a feeling going by the elevators, | 12:08 | |
(audience chatter drowns out Payne) | 12:09 | |
but what is also happening is | 12:10 | |
people are just sort of trickling in, | 12:12 | |
and that by the time 1 o'clock comes, | 12:14 | |
I'm expecting to have a full theater. | 12:17 | |
That's the way it appears. | 12:20 | |
Muriel | So we go forward. | 12:22 |
- | I hear motions to go forward. | 12:24 |
All right. | 12:27 | |
1 P.M. to 2:45 P.M. | 12:29 | |
Emerging Scholarship on Miss Ella Baker | 12:33 | |
and Grassroots Organizing, | 12:36 | |
the moderator is Joanne Grant, the panelists are | 12:37 | |
Hasan Jeffries, Abigail Lewis, and Barbara Ransby. | 12:41 | |
That will be held in Room E2. | 12:47 | |
There will be a film, Eyes on the Prize, | 12:55 | |
a segment of Ain't Scared of Your Jails with discussion -- | 13:00 | |
Actually -- | 13:03 | |
Dr. Payne. | 13:06 | |
- | [Woman In Audience] Charles. | 13:08 |
- | Charles Payne. | 13:09 |
Ain't Scared of Your Jails. | 13:13 | |
The film. | 13:16 | |
We're on the second panel. | 13:18 | |
Muriel | He doesn't know what you're talking about. | 13:21 |
- | The film Ain't Scared of Your Jails? | 13:22 |
Muriel | Where? | 13:24 |
- | Is that gonna be shown today | |
or just discussed today? | 13:26 | |
Payne | It was gonna be both shown and discussed. | 13:28 |
- | Today, right? | 13:30 |
Okay. | 13:32 | |
Where are we showing the film? | 13:33 | |
(microphone does not pick up Payne's answer) | 13:35 | |
- | All right, that'll be in Room E3. | 13:39 |
Something's a little bit different about that for me. | 13:44 | |
The third one is SNCC Culture: What Held Us Together. | 13:46 | |
Gosh, and it must have been a lot of talking | 13:50 | |
and dialoguing and arguing and getting points across. | 13:52 | |
All right. | 13:57 | |
We're gonna stay together. | 13:59 | |
Ivanhoe Donaldson, Jim Foreman, Judy Richardson, | 14:00 | |
and Charles Sherrod are on that panel, | 14:04 | |
and that will be in Room E4 in the Civic Center. | 14:06 | |
The fourth session, Black and White, Together or Separate. | 14:11 | |
Panelists are Joan Browning, Martha Norman | 14:15 | |
if she gets here, she's driving down, | 14:19 | |
Muriel Tillinghast, and Bob Zellner. | 14:21 | |
That will be in Room E5. | 14:25 | |
Organizing: The Mississippi Experience. | 14:30 | |
Panelists are Sam Block, Laurence -- | 14:33 | |
Is it Guyot or -- Guyot, | 14:36 | |
Mary Lane and Wazir Peacock. | 14:39 | |
That will be in Room D3. | 14:42 | |
- | [Person In Audience] If it is, it's in the room | 14:47 |
with Eyes on the Prize. | 14:48 | |
Woman On Panel | No, you said D. | 14:50 |
Muriel | D as in David. | 14:52 |
- | D for David, 3. | 14:53 |
The first one was E, as in elephant. | 14:55 | |
Time now is 3 to 4:45. | 14:59 | |
Telling Our Story: Women in the Movement, | 15:03 | |
will be the Deep in Our Hearts book authors, | 15:05 | |
we didn't get their names so I can't tell you | 15:08 | |
who all those folks are, but | 15:10 | |
that will be in room E2. | 15:13 | |
Teaching the Movement: What Do Students Learn from It? | 15:18 | |
John Ditmore, Martha Norman, Cleveland Sellers. | 15:21 | |
That will be in Room E3. | 15:26 | |
Teaching the Movement through Music: Song Leaders, | 15:32 | |
Betty Feitz, that booming voice, | 15:35 | |
Sam Block, Wazir Peacock, and Bill Pearlman. | 15:38 | |
That will be in E4. | 15:43 | |
Group-Centered Leadership: What Did We Learn in the 60s? | 15:48 | |
Charlie Cobb, MacArthur Cotton, Casey Hayden. | 15:51 | |
Room E5. | 15:57 | |
Where Are We Today? Issues of Race, Justice, and Peace. | 16:01 | |
James Lawson, Charles Sherrod. | 16:05 | |
Room D, David, 2. | 16:08 | |
Another film, Freedom on My Mind | 16:13 | |
and the discussion following that is Victoria Gray. | 16:16 | |
That will be in Room D3. | 16:20 | |
D like David. | 16:26 | |
The Research Committee Room will be announced | 16:35 | |
because it'll have to be one of the rooms | 16:38 | |
that you are exiting from. | 16:39 | |
So find me and we'll have that | 16:43 | |
taken care of for you by that time. | 16:45 | |
I might as well continue with the rest of what's here | 16:48 | |
for Thursday so that you can note that right now. | 16:50 | |
Dinner break is on your own. | 16:56 | |
Moore Square is right up the street, | 16:59 | |
and other nearby restaurants. | 17:00 | |
I'm coming back. | 17:02 | |
At 7, here in Estey Hall, | 17:03 | |
the showing of Fundy, with a discussion following that. | 17:08 | |
Miss Ella Baker: Developing Grassroots Leadership. | 17:13 | |
The moderator is Dr. Willie High and the panelists | 17:16 | |
are Joanne Grant, Charles Sherrod. | 17:18 | |
That will be here in this room. | 17:21 | |
I see some hands, yes. | 17:24 | |
Audience Member | Just a point of information, | 17:27 |
this weekend, it's the shutdown of | 17:31 | |
the IMF World Bank WTO too in D.C. | 17:33 | |
There are two buses going from North Carolina, | 17:38 | |
one from Chapel Hill, two blocks | 17:40 | |
up the street from UNC-Chapel Hill. | 17:42 | |
One going from Durham with students from Central and Duke. | 17:45 | |
We leave on Saturday morning at 6 A.M. | 17:48 | |
and 8 A.M. respectively. | 17:51 | |
So many of us will not be able to participate | 17:52 | |
in the big day on Saturday. | 17:55 | |
So I'm really taking issue with that, | 17:56 | |
go to lunch now, kind of a rigid schedule, | 17:58 | |
but people seem to want to continue discussion | 18:01 | |
and I'd just like to say is it possible for us | 18:05 | |
to continue discussion for those who want to do that? | 18:08 | |
- | Yes, and I was going to say that. | 18:11 |
Audience Member | There's great stories | 18:12 |
being told and I think it would be great | 18:13 | |
to hear some of those other stories. | 18:15 | |
I'd like to tell my share of the story too. | 18:17 | |
From 1966. | 18:20 | |
- | I agree with that totally. | |
And that was going to be my final statement, | 18:23 | |
that if anybody was obliged to stay here and converse, | 18:25 | |
you may continue to do so. | 18:28 | |
Again, that's why we try to provide | 18:30 | |
the chatrooms, so that these kinds of discussions | 18:32 | |
could go on in those places and the rest | 18:35 | |
of the program could continue. | 18:38 | |
I see another hand. | 18:40 | |
- | [Woman In Audience] Yes, would you tell me | 18:41 |
the room that third chatroom is gonna be located in? | 18:42 | |
- | The Board Room. Yes. | 18:46 |
In the Civic Center. | 18:49 | |
Please enter the Civic Center from | 18:51 | |
the Wilmington Street side. | 18:53 | |
There is some major conference going on | 18:57 | |
where people are entering the South Street side | 18:59 | |
and they have security, so you will not | 19:02 | |
be allowed in that entrance. | 19:05 | |
Please enter the Civic Center from | 19:07 | |
the Wilmington Street side. | 19:09 | |
- | And I frankly was on the Albany Freedom Ride because | 19:12 |
(static) | 19:15 | |
He bought all the tickets he said | 19:17 | |
he had money to buy, which was nine tickets. | 19:18 | |
One person had to be the observer, | 19:21 | |
and of the eight people who were like me, | 19:23 | |
who were to subject themselves to arrest, | 19:26 | |
he wanted it to be four white and four black. | 19:28 | |
So we had Bob who was white, and Tom Hayden, | 19:31 | |
and a wonderful redheaded bearded Dane, | 19:34 | |
on a brider from Denmark, and the -- | 19:40 | |
Man On Panel | Pier Larson. | 19:43 |
- | Pier Larson. | 19:45 |
My boyfriend at the time, Bill Humphries, | 19:46 | |
wanted to be the fourth white person, | 19:50 | |
but he was at the Georgia Institute of Technology | 19:52 | |
on an Air Force ROTC scholarship, | 19:54 | |
and he knew that life was gonna be really miserable | 19:56 | |
for him if he went on a Freedom Ride and were arrested, | 19:59 | |
so it's almost an accident of history that I had | 20:01 | |
the right skin color to be an Albany Freedom Rider. | 20:04 | |
I echo what you've heard from Charlie -- | 20:09 | |
Man On Panel | And Casey was the observer. | 20:12 |
- | She was the observer. | 20:13 |
- | Hollis and Charlie have talked about regional issues | 20:15 |
having an influence almost as strongly as racial issues. | 20:19 | |
I was a Southerner and I felt a little intimidated | 20:25 | |
about 1963 when all these brilliant Northern people | 20:29 | |
started coming down much more articulate | 20:32 | |
than I ever could aspire to be. | 20:34 | |
So I understand a little of that | 20:37 | |
regional sensitivity. | 20:41 | |
As a white person, I knew that I, | 20:45 | |
particularly as a white woman, because understand now | 20:48 | |
that white supremacy is based on the fact | 20:50 | |
that the elite white men in the South wanted to be sure | 20:52 | |
they passed on their property to their heirs. | 20:55 | |
And the way that they could do that is they had to be sure | 20:59 | |
that babies born to white women were their progeny. | 21:02 | |
So white women were captured and dealt with -- | 21:08 | |
There were a lot of ways of dealing with that, | 21:12 | |
including becoming a white supremacist yourself. | 21:13 | |
White women were a special target | 21:16 | |
of the Klan from the 20s on. | 21:20 | |
People don't generally know it, | 21:22 | |
but some white women were lynched, | 21:23 | |
particularly white women who crossed the racial lines. | 21:25 | |
So I knew that being a white women brought | 21:30 | |
a lot of new wrath, more wrath than might | 21:33 | |
otherwise be in place in demonstrations and in the movement. | 21:37 | |
And for that reason and others | 21:41 | |
I was really anxious to be told what to do. | 21:44 | |
I never aspired to be a leader. | 21:47 | |
I didn't think I had the smarts to know | 21:50 | |
the kinds of situations that my family | 21:52 | |
and others in the South had created. | 21:54 | |
I was delighted to be a part of SNCC | 21:57 | |
and part of those times. | 22:01 | |
Even today as I work for the kinds of things, | 22:05 | |
and I'm a local person, I have a major case | 22:08 | |
of local person-itis, I can only do it interracial. | 22:11 | |
I live in a place that's only 5% minority, | 22:16 | |
but I cannot work in a group that's not interracial. | 22:18 | |
Even today. | 22:23 | |
And I would really hope that you young people | 22:24 | |
find it uncomfortable to do that too. | 22:27 | |
We're going this way. | 22:31 | |
- | Well I was just getting ready to give it to Zellner. | 22:34 |
Joan | Well, you know I'm not a leader. | 22:37 |
- | That's okay. | 22:39 |
Well, okay. | 22:41 | |
With regard to what I thought we were going to talk about, | 22:43 | |
I thought that we were in fact going to not just talk about | 22:49 | |
what happened then, but that we would also try | 22:53 | |
to project into the current situation. | 22:56 | |
Perhaps you spent enough time visiting the past | 23:01 | |
so I will speak to what I think young people | 23:04 | |
ought to be thinking about doing and how. | 23:09 | |
I work with, and I try to continue | 23:12 | |
to work with young people. | 23:15 | |
First of all, because as an aging, | 23:17 | |
I'd like to say revolutionary, | 23:19 | |
but sort of an aging angry progressive, | 23:20 | |
I like to keep in with young people for several reasons. | 23:23 | |
One, because they keep you young. | 23:28 | |
Their ideas are fresh. They are new. | 23:30 | |
They have a higher level of energy | 23:33 | |
so that 18 to 20 hours a day is not | 23:35 | |
an impossible day for them. | 23:38 | |
In that regard, I work with a group in Boston | 23:42 | |
that called Center for Campus Organizers, | 23:45 | |
and I'd like to encourage you to be a part of that group | 23:48 | |
if you've never heard of it before, | 23:51 | |
and I'd be glad to talk to you later. | 23:53 | |
I also work in prisons where I see a lot of young people. | 23:56 | |
One of the things that occurred to me, | 24:01 | |
and I've often thought about SNCC, | 24:03 | |
because it was a life-transforming process, | 24:04 | |
is that in some cases we did not | 24:08 | |
recognize or appreciate our place in history. | 24:10 | |
This morning I indicated that we | 24:12 | |
did see ourselves moving the Earth. | 24:14 | |
That's a lonely spot to be in | 24:18 | |
and you have quite a bit of weight on you | 24:20 | |
and it's singular. | 24:23 | |
When I say that, most of us in SNCC | 24:24 | |
use SNCC as the family base, because those other people | 24:28 | |
had now divorced themselves for one reason or another. | 24:30 | |
Either they thought we had lost our minds | 24:33 | |
or that we would engage in something | 24:35 | |
for which they would ultimately have to answer. | 24:37 | |
So we clung to each other pretty tightly. | 24:40 | |
The point, however, is that | 24:43 | |
we did not -- | 24:46 | |
What's the word. | 24:49 | |
We did not transition well the next forces to come in. | 24:50 | |
There were efforts on the part of SNCC | 24:54 | |
to reach out laterally to the Panthers, | 24:56 | |
and that's a whole other story. | 24:57 | |
There was an effort to develop white organizing, | 24:59 | |
but that went off half-cocked to my viewpoint | 25:02 | |
because of what happened within SNCC. | 25:05 | |
I don't think that it had a good transition. | 25:07 | |
Then we also issued people in Palestine, | 25:10 | |
which alienated most of the Jewish people, | 25:13 | |
so then we were financially strapped. | 25:16 | |
Basically right in a lot of ways | 25:19 | |
and advanced in a lot of ways, but never having | 25:23 | |
laid the groundwork. | 25:26 | |
Of course, at the same time, COINTELPRO | 25:28 | |
was wreaking havoc with us. | 25:30 | |
Man On Panel | Does everyone know what | 25:35 |
COINTELPRO is? | 25:36 | |
- | You can't have it both ways. | |
Oh, COINTELPRO was the government intelligence program | 25:38 | |
which was an infiltration, it was really | 25:41 | |
the equivalent of a buy-and-bust, | 25:44 | |
only this time intellectually. | 25:46 | |
Infiltrate and kill them. | 25:49 | |
If you have to do it physically, okay, | 25:51 | |
but if you just confuse them, we'll go with that. | 25:53 | |
If you can -- What's the word. | 25:56 | |
Yeah, it's a high-level disinformation issue, | 26:00 | |
and I worked in the finance office. | 26:03 | |
I have to tell you how I heard this story. | 26:05 | |
I was in the finance office of SNCC | 26:06 | |
and we used to hear a lot of stuff | 26:08 | |
and one time Foreman got a phone call | 26:10 | |
from somebody, because when you do good things | 26:12 | |
there's always a little birdie. | 26:15 | |
It may not be a big birdie, may not be the eagle you want, | 26:16 | |
but you can find a canary every so often. | 26:18 | |
We got a call from Washington from a source | 26:20 | |
that was well-placed that essentially said | 26:24 | |
that the joint chief of staff have now had a meeting | 26:27 | |
and they have made a decision, and you're gonna have to go. | 26:30 | |
Part of that was in terms of that internationalism | 26:34 | |
that I began to talk to you briefly about this morning, | 26:37 | |
that you're just getting too big for your britches. | 26:41 | |
We can't fathom you, we can't control you, | 26:43 | |
we don't know which way you're going, | 26:46 | |
and you're asking some pretty fundamental | 26:48 | |
questions along the way. | 26:50 | |
A lot of what we were about was -- | 26:52 | |
People talk about blacks and whites, | 26:55 | |
we had Asians, we had all kinds of people in SNCC. | 26:57 | |
We had gays, non-gays, we had a few heroin addicts. | 27:00 | |
You know, we had a few people from every walk of life | 27:05 | |
but one of the things that we were was a place | 27:08 | |
where, whatever your past was, we tried to be able | 27:11 | |
to transform you into something else, | 27:15 | |
that we work together as a catalyst in that process. | 27:17 | |
Having said all that, one of the things | 27:21 | |
that I've spent some time thinking about is | 27:22 | |
what happens when the intellectual head of a movement dies? | 27:25 | |
Because that's what happened to SNCC in many ways. | 27:31 | |
We spent a lot of time weeding | 27:34 | |
and a lot of time trying to plow the land in front of us, | 27:35 | |
but as I said, we had no back troops. | 27:38 | |
Our own physical situation was one of exhaustion. | 27:41 | |
I gave you an idea of eating once a week, | 27:45 | |
that kind of extreme strain. | 27:47 | |
I didn't tell you about people who could not | 27:51 | |
stay in the same place for more than 12 hours | 27:53 | |
because they were being looked for by dogs | 27:55 | |
and anything else walking. | 27:58 | |
It was open season on shooting them. | 28:00 | |
This was not always the case, but it was enough of the case | 28:03 | |
for people to understand that you could not really | 28:06 | |
get settled wherever you were. | 28:08 | |
If you were not in the middle of | 28:11 | |
either a major cultural redefinition, | 28:14 | |
I'll use that for the White Sisters Council | 28:18 | |
and all other kinds of things, | 28:21 | |
then you were gonna be the recipient of somebody | 28:23 | |
who was coming out of that, and you had to be ready | 28:25 | |
to move to be of assistance. | 28:27 | |
SNCC, in many ways to me, was the | 28:30 | |
intellectual leadership of the movement. | 28:31 | |
It spawned a lot of thought and people were willing | 28:33 | |
to go out and develop those ideas and make them happen. | 28:36 | |
Having the intellectual leadership of this operation | 28:41 | |
mark itself down in what I consider internal racialism | 28:45 | |
was a real step to the rear as far as I was concerned. | 28:49 | |
I wasn't a part of it, I always | 28:53 | |
spoke against it to anyone who cared. | 28:54 | |
There were times where our leadership was | 28:58 | |
really not under a collectivity, | 29:00 | |
if I could just say it that way, | 29:03 | |
that it was more singular. | 29:05 | |
So people set up the singular style | 29:06 | |
and they went that in, as far as I'm concerned, | 29:08 | |
a direction that did not have everybody on board with it. | 29:11 | |
But be that as it may, that's history | 29:15 | |
and that is what has happened. | 29:17 | |
I believe too that the world has to be -- | 29:19 | |
You live in the present, and so the organization | 29:23 | |
that you work with ought to look like | 29:25 | |
the group of people you want to live with. | 29:27 | |
There's no such thing as moving it, | 29:30 | |
'I'm going to do it down the line.' | 29:32 | |
You may not have down the line, | 29:35 | |
all you have is today, you know? | 29:36 | |
So the people that you work with, | 29:39 | |
the people that you respect, the people that you | 29:41 | |
cohabit with, the people that you swap lies with, | 29:43 | |
et cetera, are all the people around which | 29:47 | |
you should surround yourself and your current situation. | 29:50 | |
I encourage people not to look at what we did historically, | 29:53 | |
but to look at where you are in your classes, | 29:57 | |
to make your classroom work serious, | 30:00 | |
to start doing research where it counts. | 30:03 | |
I mean, those silly little research projects on whatever, | 30:06 | |
you can turn it, you can make it politically right. | 30:09 | |
You can raise the questions in class. | 30:13 | |
You should be -- | 30:15 | |
Everything in the bibliography, ace out the professor, | 30:16 | |
turn the class around on him or her | 30:19 | |
and say, 'And what about so-and-so? | 30:23 | |
'And what about so-and-so?' | 30:25 | |
So that you have dealt with the class. | 30:27 | |
That's a basic. | 30:29 | |
The leadership in the 21st century | 30:31 | |
has got to be technologically ept. | 30:33 | |
You just can't be angry and you just can't be cross-eyed. | 30:36 | |
You've got to have technology, | 30:38 | |
you've got to be able to finesse and work with people, | 30:40 | |
you've got to be able to negotiate, | 30:42 | |
and you need to be able to walk from a prison cell | 30:44 | |
to a corporate boardroom in the same breath | 30:46 | |
and be able to move both of those parallels together | 30:49 | |
and come out with something that's common. | 30:53 | |
You're constantly synthesizing. | 30:55 | |
You're constantly raising the correct questions, | 30:58 | |
not the questions that get pushed, necessarily, | 31:00 | |
because you will find special interests is very apt | 31:03 | |
at changing and massaging what you say. | 31:07 | |
Responsibility. | 31:12 | |
I find that Northerners, for example, when they organize, | 31:14 | |
try to organize on a union kind of model. | 31:16 | |
You have a particular interest with me, | 31:19 | |
I'm trying to work this with you. | 31:20 | |
The nature of human rights is much broader than that. | 31:23 | |
Everybody, white people, ought to recognize | 31:27 | |
that racialism and racism has worked to their detriment. | 31:30 | |
And that's hard to explain to white people | 31:34 | |
who feel like at this juncture, the world is their oyster. | 31:36 | |
But spend some analysis, in terms of reversing | 31:40 | |
what is considered and normative | 31:42 | |
so that you can, in fact, have new information, | 31:44 | |
new perspectives to bring. | 31:46 | |
That's kind of it for me right now. | 31:49 | |
(gospel music) | 31:50 | |
- | It's wonderful to hear such good sense, | 31:54 |
such good sense and so clear. | 31:57 | |
To me, it's clear. | 32:00 | |
I think we all know enough to know | 32:03 | |
that what you're talking about is very good. | 32:05 | |
I'm a little puzzled also about | 32:10 | |
what was the slogan for today? | 32:13 | |
Thanksgiving? | 32:15 | |
(gospel music drowns out speech) | 32:16 | |
(laughter) | 32:17 | |
Are they scared of you in jails? | 32:17 | |
Black and White? | 32:18 | |
Audience | Together and Separate. | 32:20 |
- | Together and Separate, okay, good. | 32:21 |
Well, they're all relevant. | 32:22 | |
[Joan] Every seminar, every session is the same. | 32:27 | |
(laughter) | 32:29 | |
- | You have different things to say at different ones. | 32:31 |
I did do a little bit of thinking beforehand, | 32:34 | |
which I normally don't, I just | 32:37 | |
bounce off of things that are going. | 32:39 | |
I see some of my students here also. | 32:42 | |
Natalie and Jeff for sure, anybody else? | 32:46 | |
Natalie | No, it's just us. | 32:50 |
- | If you've heard it all before, | 32:51 |
just say, 'Hey, you're going over the same stuff again.' | 32:53 | |
I did a little thinking and I looked back at what | 32:57 | |
Clayborne Carson said in one of the editions, | 33:00 | |
maybe the last edition to In Struggle. | 33:04 | |
He put it very simply. | 33:09 | |
He said that around the middle 60s, sometime after '64, | 33:11 | |
SNCC, and to a larger extent, the civil rights movement | 33:16 | |
in the South, gave up three terrific weapons | 33:21 | |
that they had used to very good effect. | 33:25 | |
They gave up basically -- | 33:28 | |
Come in. Join us. | 33:32 | |
We are discussing today | 33:36 | |
White and Black: Together or Separate. | 33:38 | |
Glad I know that now. | 33:41 | |
(laughter) | 33:42 | |
Clayborne Carson in the introduction to his book | 33:46 | |
posed the question, first a problem and then a question. | 33:50 | |
He says that around the middle 60s, SNCC and the movement | 33:54 | |
gave up three tremendously potent weapons | 33:58 | |
that had gotten them a long distance. | 34:02 | |
Grassroots community organizing, because basically | 34:04 | |
we did a pullout of Mississippi | 34:08 | |
and part of the rationale for that | 34:12 | |
was we'd produced local leadership, | 34:15 | |
we work ourselves out of the job and go. | 34:17 | |
So we had a rationale for that, | 34:19 | |
but basically it was a pullout. | 34:22 | |
Secession, at least for a long time, | 34:25 | |
on a nationally-organized level | 34:28 | |
of doing grassroots community work | 34:30 | |
where you burrow into the community, | 34:33 | |
develop ties that Muriel was talking about. | 34:34 | |
The other was that they gave up in a large measure | 34:37 | |
nonviolent direct action. | 34:41 | |
Nonviolent direct action was still used in some cases | 34:44 | |
and so forth, but basically it was not | 34:46 | |
one of the three strong arrows in the quiver anymore. | 34:51 | |
Thirdly, basically gave up interracial work, | 34:54 | |
which in terms of SNCC had been part of the keystone | 34:59 | |
of what we had always talked about | 35:02 | |
because we realized, I think very early on, | 35:06 | |
maybe under the leadership of Ella Baker and others, | 35:09 | |
that you're never gonna reach a time | 35:12 | |
when everything is the way you want it | 35:13 | |
and it's gonna stay that way from then on. | 35:16 | |
We learned that struggle is a constant struggle, | 35:19 | |
and therefore whatever society that you want in general, | 35:22 | |
you should have that society for yourself. | 35:25 | |
Part of that beloved community was | 35:29 | |
that it would be interracial. | 35:31 | |
One of the things that's happening to history | 35:34 | |
and the telling of the story in the last 25 or 30 years | 35:36 | |
is that a lot of times that has been overlooked | 35:40 | |
or underplayed to such an extent -- | 35:44 | |
Let me stand up here. | 35:48 | |
It's been underplayed to such an extent | 35:50 | |
that many people don't realize that the early movement | 35:52 | |
was quite incredibly integrated. | 35:55 | |
Some people are aware of a few of us who did certain things, | 35:59 | |
but in a lot of ways, the movement was very integrated. | 36:02 | |
Now, the question that Clayborne Carson asked | 36:06 | |
after saying we gave up those three weapons. | 36:12 | |
He said, "What took the place of those | 36:17 | |
weapons in the movement?" | 36:19 | |
And that is a question that I've heard him pose, | 36:22 | |
I've never heard a thorough investigation of that question. | 36:25 | |
If we're going into nationalism, | 36:32 | |
if we're going into all of those elements | 36:34 | |
that have, if you're a dialectician you believe | 36:36 | |
that they had positive and negative aspects. | 36:39 | |
Part of the reason for giving up the grassroots community | 36:44 | |
and the nonviolent direct action and | 36:48 | |
the interracial work together was | 36:51 | |
the move for the nationalists' point of view. | 36:53 | |
And that, to me, is the period that we're still in. | 36:56 | |
We have not yet answered those questions, | 36:59 | |
we have not yet really had a thorough | 37:03 | |
going examination on it and say, | 37:05 | |
'Okay, if, in fact, we've given up those weapons, | 37:08 | |
'how do we -- Do we need to take them up, | 37:11 | |
'along with what other weapons?' | 37:14 | |
Number one is we always talk about biracial, | 37:16 | |
black and white, and now it's not a question | 37:19 | |
of biracial black and white, it's multiracial, | 37:22 | |
racial, it's multicultural. | 37:25 | |
The kind of organizing that many of us are doing today -- | 37:28 | |
For instance, last night, I conducted | 37:31 | |
a nonviolent workshop in Southampton, New York. | 37:33 | |
This was after five people had been arrested | 37:38 | |
and injured, some of them quite severely. | 37:40 | |
I was beaten up by the state troopers. | 37:44 | |
My right arm, and I made a pledge to myself | 37:47 | |
that I'm gonna do this, as hokey as it is, | 37:51 | |
because the report from the New York State Police | 37:54 | |
and everybody is no injuries. | 37:57 | |
Black people were arrested. | 38:00 | |
And if you'll look at my two arms, | 38:02 | |
this arm right here is so severely dislocated, | 38:05 | |
it'll never actually be the same again. | 38:08 | |
This is after the arm has basically healed. | 38:11 | |
Ripped open with tendons and everything. | 38:14 | |
They trained these cops, by the way, | 38:16 | |
to concentrate now on soft tissue and on joints. | 38:20 | |
They don't break the major bones, | 38:24 | |
that's gonna show up in an x-ray. | 38:26 | |
They broke my left leg in the knee, | 38:28 | |
broke my arm in the elbow. | 38:31 | |
They also knocked my jaw out of place, | 38:34 | |
which has been knocked out of place before | 38:36 | |
a number of times, and now I have some kind of PMS. | 38:39 | |
Or uh ... | 38:42 | |
Joan | TMJ. | 38:44 |
- | TMJ. | 38:45 |
(laughter) | 38:45 | |
Muriel | Not close. | 38:47 |
- | That too. | 38:51 |
I can have both of them, and I've got a .38 in my purse. | 38:58 | |
(laughter) | 39:02 | |
- | What we're talking about basically | 39:07 |
is something that is still happening today. | 39:08 | |
I mean this is a Shinnecock reservation. | 39:11 | |
We have so many situations -- | 39:14 | |
And when those cops started beating me, | 39:15 | |
first of all, they dragged me over behind cars. | 39:17 | |
Four or five of those cops beat me, working on my joints. | 39:20 | |
They broke this arm twice, and then when they put me | 39:23 | |
in the paddywagon, the slammed the door on that arm. | 39:26 | |
I mean, I had never ever had such excruciating -- | 39:30 | |
And nonviolent, you're supposed to be cool, right? | 39:33 | |
The kid was screaming, you know? | 39:36 | |
I said, I am -- I was 60 years old and since then | 39:40 | |
I've had a birthday, I'm 61 years old. | 39:42 | |
My bones are not that resilient anymore, okay? | 39:45 | |
But what I'm saying is we're still doing the same thing. | 39:48 | |
We're so trained that the situation develops, | 39:53 | |
we just go there and do it, but y'all gonna have to do it | 39:56 | |
now because we're getting too old. | 39:59 | |
Used to be we would spring back right away. | 40:01 | |
Going around, I have debated whether or not | 40:05 | |
to bring my walking stick, because I remember Danny Lyon | 40:07 | |
had something temporarily wrong with him, | 40:10 | |
he brought his walking stick. | 40:12 | |
Ever since then, I've been thinking about | 40:13 | |
poor Danny Lyon walking around with a walking stick. | 40:15 | |
And everybody says, 'Bob, you're really getting old. | 40:18 | |
'You've got a walking stick.' | 40:20 | |
What I'm talking about is what it's gonna take -- | 40:24 | |
How are we gonna get back together? | 40:27 | |
And are we gonna say, can we get back together | 40:29 | |
without really dealing with the time? | 40:32 | |
And a lot of times we approach it, | 40:34 | |
we don't really deal with it. | 40:35 | |
Maybe there were some mistakes made. | 40:37 | |
Obviously, SNCC went out of existence | 40:39 | |
in terms of an organization. | 40:42 | |
SNCC never died in terms of a spirit. | 40:44 | |
In fact, they might've done us a favor | 40:47 | |
in that we were gonna be like -- | 40:50 | |
Who was it, they shot Big Bill? | 40:51 | |
Bill Haywood? Yeah. | 40:58 | |
He was always gonna be around wherever they were struggling. | 41:00 | |
At least that's what we're doing. | 41:03 | |
But what I want to tell you is | 41:05 | |
that we need to tighten it up. | 41:07 | |
We've got a lot of things right there in Southampton. | 41:10 | |
Now they're less embarrassed about being racist | 41:13 | |
and beating up people in Southampton now | 41:16 | |
than there would be in Southampton, Virginia. | 41:18 | |
Southampton, Virginia, that would be all over the news. | 41:22 | |
But they can beat up Indian activists | 41:25 | |
and Indian community people and poor | 41:27 | |
old aging activists up in Southampton. | 41:30 | |
And you know what they do? | 41:33 | |
They do put it in the New York Times. | 41:34 | |
In the Long Island Edition. | 41:36 | |
They put it in Newsday in the Long Island Edition. | 41:38 | |
If it gets in anything else other | 41:41 | |
than the Long Island Edition, it gets | 41:43 | |
in the Metro section of the New York Times. | 41:44 | |
They don't even put it so that the Indian activists | 41:47 | |
in the northern part of the states can do it. | 41:50 | |
But Danny Lyons -- You know that Danny's | 41:54 | |
working on a book now on American Indian activism? | 41:56 | |
And he says that around the reservations and all the places, | 41:59 | |
they're looking at what's happening in Shinnecock, | 42:03 | |
and I'm wondering how is the information getting out? | 42:05 | |
We do have a movement grapevine and everything. | 42:08 | |
So I'm just telling you that what happened then | 42:11 | |
is really basically the same things | 42:14 | |
that we're faced with now. | 42:16 | |
So we're having to go through a whole new process | 42:18 | |
of organizing people, getting them together, | 42:20 | |
and talking about that situation of jail, | 42:23 | |
and also the situation of allies. | 42:26 | |
In the situation with the Shinnecocks, | 42:29 | |
there's a tradition of being very close, | 42:31 | |
very dignified, very secretive and everything. | 42:33 | |
Now, they're reaching out for allies | 42:36 | |
not only among other native activists and everything, | 42:39 | |
but also in the white community. | 42:42 | |
I've been appointed the, what is it, | 42:46 | |
Co-Chair of the Anti-Bias Task Force in Southampton. | 42:49 | |
And they've made a mistake, I know that they | 42:54 | |
didn't know this was gonna happen. | 42:56 | |
Never appoint an old activist to some kind of town | 42:57 | |
position, because they expect that you're gonna be | 43:01 | |
respectable and deferential and everything like that. | 43:04 | |
But we have a habit of calling things like they are. | 43:07 | |
First of all, we did something that was symbolic. | 43:12 | |
The town has a seal, and it's a big white pilgrim. | 43:17 | |
Big white pilgrim with a rock over one shoulder | 43:22 | |
and a big three-masted schooner over the other shoulder. | 43:24 | |
We don't even have Plymouth Rock and the Mayflower | 43:28 | |
in Southampton, but they're using all this imagery, right? | 43:32 | |
So we made a modest proposal that we would change that, | 43:35 | |
and the vitriol that came out in the papers and everything. | 43:39 | |
'Who is this guy? Where'd he come from? | 43:43 | |
'Where is this Jew Zellner? | 43:45 | |
'I bet he's only been in this country 20 years. | 43:49 | |
'Messing with our seal,' and everything like that. | 43:53 | |
So then we said, 'Okay, we'll make a deal with you. | 43:58 | |
'You keep the white man, but let's have | 44:00 | |
some hiring in the town.' | 44:03 | |
Because now we have about one third of this town, | 44:06 | |
Southampton, is minority, people of color, | 44:09 | |
Asians, Hispanics, Native Americans. | 44:12 | |
In the 338 people hired by our town in Southampton, | 44:16 | |
19 are people of color. | 44:21 | |
One is an American Indian. | 44:23 | |
And in the school, which gets $8 to 12 million a year, | 44:26 | |
there is one Native American hired in the school. | 44:31 | |
That is incredible. | 44:34 | |
They've had an affirmative action plan in place since 1979. | 44:37 | |
So when we begin to find out those things, | 44:43 | |
we had to tell the truth. | 44:45 | |
And then pretty soon, we had people | 44:47 | |
marching on Town Hall, we had people standing behind | 44:48 | |
the town board with signs saying 'shame on the board,' | 44:51 | |
and people taking pictures of the board | 44:54 | |
and there's that white pilgrim up there. | 44:57 | |
But we started joking about the pilgrim. | 45:02 | |
We thought, 'Well, maybe we can demystify.' | 45:04 | |
Do you know why a pilgrim's pants always fall down? | 45:05 | |
Because he has his buckle on his hat. | 45:09 | |
(laughter) | 45:12 | |
But my point is, and this is the last thing I'm saying. | 45:19 | |
My point is that if we transition the organizing | 45:22 | |
that we're doing now, in Southampton College, | 45:25 | |
in the town and everything, on the reservation. | 45:28 | |
If we try to do that without having | 45:31 | |
all races of people together and black and white | 45:33 | |
working together, boy we'd be ridiculous. | 45:36 | |
We could not do it. | 45:39 | |
So especially getting ready for the world that we're in now, | 45:40 | |
with the globalization and everything, | 45:43 | |
the mechanization, learning all this stuff | 45:45 | |
about computers and everything, | 45:47 | |
we're old to learn that. | 45:48 | |
That's so natural to you guys. | 45:50 | |
We can't even talk about being -- | 45:53 | |
We can talk about nationalism. | 45:55 | |
We can talk about those feelings. | 45:57 | |
We can talk about positive aspects of that, | 45:59 | |
but in terms of working together | 46:01 | |
and making a movement, we have to constantly | 46:02 | |
change our ideas about doing it | 46:05 | |
multi-culturally, multi-racially, multi-nationally, | 46:07 | |
and all those ways. | 46:11 | |
That means black and white have to work together. | 46:12 | |
Thank you. | 46:14 | |
(applause) | 46:16 | |
Joan | We don't actually have a moderator, | 46:22 |
so Hollis, you're in the center. | 46:24 | |
Male Panelist | Hollis is the one. | 46:25 |
Zellner | Did everybody see the movie, by the way? | 46:28 |
- | Freedom Song. | 46:31 |
Zellner | Freedom Song? | |
(laughter) | 46:34 | |
Hollis is one of the main characters of the movie. | 46:36 | |
Hollis | Thumbs down on Freedom Song. | 46:39 |
We don't talk about it. | 46:43 | |
- | I want to raise another aspect of it. | 46:45 |
I'm Teresa Del Pozzo and I worked with SNCC | 46:49 | |
first in Wisconsin as a support person | 46:53 | |
spreading the word in Wisconsin | 47:00 | |
and in the student community, | 47:03 | |
and then through a larger community about the summer | 47:05 | |
project, about what was happening in the South. | 47:08 | |
At that time, when I first started doing that, | 47:11 | |
I was stunned to find out that most white people | 47:15 | |
didn't know that black people couldn't vote in the South. | 47:18 | |
There was a lot of educating to be done. | 47:27 | |
Then there was the summer project came along. | 47:31 | |
And I want to raise the question about -- | 47:34 | |
We talked a lot about the community organizing of SNCC, | 47:37 | |
but there was also another side of SNCC which was | 47:43 | |
sometimes in conflict with this idea and sometimes not. | 47:48 | |
And that was reaching the larger national community. | 47:53 | |
The debate that has always gone on | 47:58 | |
was that the recognition was that unless white people | 48:02 | |
were also targeted the way black people | 48:08 | |
were being targeted, there was not going to be | 48:12 | |
any concern about what was happening | 48:15 | |
to black people in Mississippi. | 48:18 | |
I would call this the approach that was targeted | 48:25 | |
at the national politics of the country, | 48:28 | |
as opposed to the community organizing. | 48:32 | |
In fact, it was true. | 48:37 | |
Because when the summer project happened | 48:40 | |
and all those people came from all over the country | 48:42 | |
and their parents became interested, | 48:45 | |
their churches became interested in what happened | 48:51 | |
in Mississippi, the local television stations | 48:53 | |
where they were were interested | 48:56 | |
in what happened in Mississippi. | 48:58 | |
For the first time, the community organizing | 49:03 | |
that had been going on in the South | 49:07 | |
was now getting a support from the national political scene. | 49:10 | |
I, for one, don't think that the gains | 49:20 | |
that were made by the movement would've ever been possible | 49:25 | |
if it had not been for that pulling together | 49:30 | |
of both the grassroots organizing | 49:34 | |
and the national attention and the spread out of that | 49:38 | |
that then had influence on the antiwar movement, | 49:45 | |
the women's movement, and all the kinds of things | 49:48 | |
that followed from that. | 49:51 | |
This is a subject that I -- | 49:56 | |
When the stuff started to happen in SNCC | 50:00 | |
where the nationalism became a reality, | 50:03 | |
to me it was just something I'd kind of expected to happen. | 50:06 | |
I knew about it as a historical phenomenon | 50:10 | |
and I had seen it in Northern situations | 50:13 | |
and I kind of expected it. | 50:17 | |
And I think that we have seen the results of it. | 50:19 | |
We've seen 30 years of results of it, | 50:23 | |
which is very splintered. | 50:25 | |
We have people constantly duplicating their efforts. | 50:29 | |
You've got the groups that are lobbying | 50:37 | |
for the condition situations in prison. | 50:40 | |
You've got people lobbying about the environment. | 50:42 | |
You've got people lobbying about local political. | 50:47 | |
You've got people arguing about the distribution | 50:52 | |
of income for schooling and education. | 50:54 | |
All those kinds of things. | 50:58 | |
And what we've all been doing, what I feel for years, | 51:00 | |
is like we're all spinning our wheels, the same wheel, | 51:04 | |
where everybody's out there working over the same issue | 51:08 | |
rather than working in a coordinated effort | 51:11 | |
because somehow we lost that track at that point in the 60s, | 51:15 | |
and I'm one who just accepts that that had to happen | 51:20 | |
because somehow that is like the history | 51:26 | |
that this country is saddled with. | 51:30 | |
That's the outcome of slavery, | 51:35 | |
that its impact was so deep and so divisive | 51:39 | |
that people would, in fact, | 51:42 | |
just as you say, give up the most successful weapons | 51:47 | |
they had and go off on another track. | 51:52 | |
I think also that we've seen from the FBI files | 51:56 | |
that have been released and the COINTEL stuff | 51:59 | |
and all of that, that there was a tremendous effort | 52:01 | |
directed at SNCC to foster this kind of divisiveness | 52:08 | |
and to set people against each other, et cetera. | 52:13 | |
I think that what Bob says is absolutely right, | 52:18 | |
as we go into this next century, | 52:22 | |
for the people who are coming up now, | 52:28 | |
I just don't see that there can be -- | 52:33 | |
To me, it almost seems ludicrous | 52:35 | |
that we're still discussing this subject. | 52:37 | |
It's so self-apparent that unless people | 52:44 | |
with the same interests, whether they're Native Americans, | 52:48 | |
whether they're African-Americans, | 52:53 | |
whether Italian-Americans or whatever, | 52:54 | |
can be unified and work together in coalitions. | 52:59 | |
I just don't see how there could be any | 53:04 | |
success for anybody. | 53:08 | |
- | I would rather not, because I'm sure | 53:15 |
you've learned from this, never bring a bunch | 53:18 | |
of us together or we do all the talking. | 53:21 | |
Always bring one or two if you want to ask a question. | 53:24 | |
He had a question. | 53:26 | |
- | Okay, wow. | 53:28 |
Hey, I'm Billy, and I'm a white kid | 53:33 | |
in case you folks are wondering. | 53:35 | |
(laughter) | 53:37 | |
Let's just start from there. | 53:43 | |
I'm having a hard time trying to frame | 53:47 | |
what I'm trying to say. | 53:48 | |
I'm understanding the stuff about, | 53:55 | |
yeah, we gotta build multiracial coalitions | 53:58 | |
and things like this, that makes sense to me. | 54:00 | |
I'm really struggling with this, | 54:04 | |
because another thing is | 54:06 | |
for example, I work with a youth organization, | 54:08 | |
defining young people as 18 and under. | 54:12 | |
We're trying to build this organization | 54:15 | |
where people 18 and under run their own organizations. | 54:17 | |
So from that perspective, I understand | 54:19 | |
this whole deal of racial separation | 54:22 | |
as far as the work that we do, on some level. | 54:25 | |
Not to say those young people shouldn't | 54:28 | |
collaborate and coalition with other people, | 54:30 | |
but they gotta run their own organization, | 54:32 | |
I understand that. | 54:34 | |
Also, I'm really, really curious | 54:38 | |
because I haven't lived in the suburbs | 54:39 | |
that I grew up in in a number of years. | 54:41 | |
I'm not particularly excited to go back there, | 54:47 | |
but I understand that -- | 54:49 | |
Who's gonna organize white suburb folks | 54:52 | |
but white suburban kids? | 54:56 | |
So I'm really, really, really curious to see | 54:58 | |
what that really looks like, you know what I mean? | 55:00 | |
It's ideal if we can figure out a way | 55:03 | |
to bring this all together, right? | 55:05 | |
Most of the world's people are not benefiting | 55:07 | |
from this system, so we should | 55:10 | |
work together to overthrow it. | 55:12 | |
But what does white organizing look like? | 55:13 | |
Hollis | Overthrow. | 55:18 |
(laughter) | 55:19 | |
- | No, but really. | 55:21 |
I guess that's my main question. | 55:22 | |
What does white organizing really look like | 55:24 | |
and how does that work? | 55:28 | |
Because this is an important question, | 55:31 | |
because I do realize that a lot of this stuff | 55:32 | |
of dismantling racism, you folks | 55:36 | |
are coming from a really unique position. | 55:38 | |
You're coming from a history of where | 55:39 | |
the white folks that were involved | 55:42 | |
were involved in a black-led organization. | 55:44 | |
That's not the reality of most | 55:46 | |
of the white organizations that exist today. | 55:48 | |
Most of the organizations with white folks in it | 55:51 | |
at this point were started by white people | 55:53 | |
with a vision by white people dominated | 55:55 | |
by a white racist culture and all this kind of thing. | 55:57 | |
And that's just very different. | 56:00 | |
So. I don't know. | 56:02 | |
Hollis | First Jimmy and then you. | 56:11 |
- | My name is Jimmy Rogers and I worked SNCC | 56:15 |
and led in Lowndes and Macon County, Alabama. | 56:18 | |
I've worked previously in Alabama. | 56:23 | |
I started working SNCC in 1965 | 56:28 | |
and the thing that most people | 56:32 | |
don't realize or they don't talk about, | 56:35 | |
the only civil rights workers in Lowndes County | 56:38 | |
to get killed were white, at least | 56:40 | |
during the time that I was there. | 56:42 | |
The first one was Viola Liuzzo, | 56:44 | |
who was the wife of a union official from Detroit | 56:47 | |
who came down to the Selma to Montgomery march, | 56:53 | |
and she was transporting people back and forth | 56:56 | |
from Montgomery to Selma and whatnot. | 56:59 | |
And in the middle of the night, | 57:02 | |
she was riding with a black man | 57:03 | |
and the Klan just happened to be | 57:05 | |
galloping behind and shot her. | 57:07 | |
Okay, the next one was Jonathan Daniels, | 57:09 | |
who worked with SNCC in Lowndes County. | 57:12 | |
One Saturday, we decided that we would | 57:19 | |
go to a town called Fort Deposit. | 57:23 | |
It was me, Jonathan, a number of other people, | 57:26 | |
and some of the local people, it was their idea. | 57:29 | |
They were very disturbed, because when black people | 57:32 | |
went to this one restaurant, they had to go | 57:36 | |
through the back window to get served. | 57:39 | |
You couldn't go inside, you know, | 57:41 | |
they hand you stuff out of the window. | 57:43 | |
We weren't allowed in the restaurant. | 57:45 | |
That Saturday, we got arrested | 57:50 | |
I think it was something like 15 of us or so, | 57:52 | |
thirteen blacks and two whites. | 57:56 | |
Well, two weeks before that time, | 58:00 | |
I happened to be in Hayneville City Hall | 58:02 | |
and this man walked up to Jonathan Daniels | 58:09 | |
and he said, 'I could understand why he's here, | 58:13 | |
'but I don't understand why you carpetbagging Yankees | 58:17 | |
'coming down here stirring up all the good black folks. | 58:21 | |
'We're gonna get you.' | 58:24 | |
And sure enough, two weeks later, | 58:26 | |
we had a demonstration, we were arrested, | 58:31 | |
we were put in jail, we stayed in jail for a week, | 58:33 | |
we got out the next week. | 58:36 | |
He walked to the store that we were all | 58:38 | |
used to going to, the people in there | 58:41 | |
were always very nice to us. | 58:44 | |
But on this day, there was a guy | 58:47 | |
standing inside the door with a shotgun, | 58:48 | |
and when he walked up, he just blew him away. | 58:51 | |
And I don't have any idea -- | 58:54 | |
I mean, I don't have any doubt | 58:56 | |
that the reason why he got shot | 58:58 | |
was because he was white. | 59:00 | |
To sum it up, what I'm trying to say is, | 59:04 | |
during that time, I think that a | 59:06 | |
white person working in Lowndes County or Macon County | 59:09 | |
and whatnot for SNCC, had much more of an impact | 59:14 | |
than black people going around | 59:17 | |
and registering people to vote. | 59:20 | |
- | I want to speak to this young man's question | 59:25 |
to tell you how I'm using some of the best | 59:28 | |
that SNCC developed, not that I did, | 59:31 | |
but the best SNCC ideas to work with white young people. | 59:33 | |
I'm part of a project called Education for Liberation, | 59:39 | |
and my assignment is to take Charlie Cobb's concept | 59:42 | |
of freedom schools and see if there's something there, | 59:45 | |
a model there to use to teach white young people | 59:48 | |
that in giving up what they perceive as white privilege, | 59:52 | |
they won't actually be much enriched and gain from that. | 59:55 | |
And that's a tough assignment, Charlie. | 59:59 | |
If you have any ideas, I'm ready for them. | 1:00:01 | |
I think it's my job to talk -- | 1:00:06 | |
I thought it was always my job to talk to white people. | 1:00:07 | |
I never thought that black people had anything | 1:00:10 | |
to learn from me, except perhaps | 1:00:11 | |
that all white people are not unified. | 1:00:14 | |
My job is to try to figure out a way | 1:00:17 | |
to explain to white people that | 1:00:20 | |
white society, white culture, European culture's | 1:00:23 | |
played its hand, it's done its thing. | 1:00:26 | |
It's been dominant for a long time. | 1:00:28 | |
There's nothing new or -- | 1:00:30 |